Why we Over-Communicate: What a One-Star Review Taught me about Setting Expectations

Published: June 2026 | Category: The Operator's Journal By Kay Honig,

Founder & CEO, Kay Tours Mexico

The One-Star Review That Changed Everything

We sold our first whale shark tour through an online booking platform in early June. First week of the season. The guests showed up, we took them out, and the experience did not unfold the way they expected.

The weather was difficult. The migration had just started and whale shark sightings in the last part of May and first weeks of June are always less predictable than mid-season. We found sharks, but conditions were rough and the encounter was brief. They came back disappointed.

The review was one star.

Here is the honest part: in our defense, early June is genuinely the trickiest window of the season. But that defense does not matter if we never told the guests what to expect. We sent them a welcome message. We told them what to bring. We did not tell them that early-season conditions are variable, that the open ocean can be rough and that this is wildlife, which means not a guaranteed show.

That is entirely on us.

That review was the trigger for everything I am about to describe.

What Guests Get Wrong About This Tour

Before I explain what we changed, I need to explain what we are up against.

Most people who book a whale shark excursion from Cancún have a mental image that looks something like this: a calm, tropical bay. Maybe 20 minutes from shore. Crystal clear water. A giant, docile fish swimming slowly underneath them while they float effortlessly on the surface, Instagram-ready, refreshed.

That is not this tour.

This is what it actually is:

• A 5:00 AM pickup from your hotel

• A 30-minute to 3-hour boat ride across open ocean to reach the feeding grounds. The travel time varies every single day depending on where the sharks are

• Two water entries of 5 to 15 minutes each, in open ocean conditions, with only 2 swimmers and 1 guide entering at a time

• Real wildlife. The whale sharks are wild animals. They do not wait for you. Some days, you find them in 30 minutes. Other days, it takes longer. On rare days, ocean conditions make the encounter brief. That unpredictability is not a flaw; it is part of what makes the experience real and worth doing.

• A physically demanding day. The ocean and the boat ride can be exhausting. The swimming is certainly exhausting. People underestimate all three and then they arrive unprepared.

I want to be clear: this is not an extreme sports tour. You do not need to be an athlete. A mandatory life jacket keeps you afloat the entire time. A guide is in the water next to you. No swimming ability beyond comfort in the water is required.

But you need to be honest with yourself about what your body is signing up for. This is not extreme, but it is genuinely demanding, and that distinction is both the hardest to explain and the most important to understand.

Why Communication Is My Job, Not the Platform's

When you book through an OTA (an online travel platform like Viator or GetYourGuide), the operator; us, loses most of the communication layer. We cannot send you automated pre-tour emails. We cannot customize your booking confirmation. Our only direct channel is the platform's internal chat, and most guests do not check that.

So the guest books, gets a standard confirmation, and shows up in the hotel lobby at 6:00 AM with no real understanding of what the day is going to look like. That is a knwledge gap, nobody else than me is to blame for. Filling it is not the platform's job; it is ours.

What We Built to Fix It

After last weeks first one-star review, I started improving (again) a communication system that works regardless of where or how a guest books. Here is what it looks like today:

The Infographic

The most recent piece, I am super happy with, since I was able to create it with a bunch of ai tools, I finished this week. A single visual that covers everything a guest needs to know before they show up: what the tour actually is, what the day looks like hour by hour, motion sickness preparation, what to bring, what to leave behind, and how we operate inside the federally protected biosphere reserve.

Why an infographic? Because people do not read past the third paragraph. I have been writing blog posts and emails for this business for over a decade. The infographic is structured, scannable, and shareable. We can attach it to OTA chat messages. We can post it to social media. We can include it in emails. It's one easy to understand asset, we can use on every channel.

The Long-Form Blog Post

We have maintained a detailed guide on our website for years. The biology of whale sharks, the exact geography of where we go, what the season looks like, what to expect in the water. It is thorough. It is also long, and most people do not read it start to finish.

It exists for the guest who wants every detail. It is also what search engines and AI assistants index when someone asks "what is a whale shark tour like in Cancun." Not sure if that actually works. I am still working on my SEO skills.

The Explainer Video

About a month ago, I built a three-minute explainer video using Claude and NotebookLM. It covers everything the long-form post does, but in a format for people who would rather watch than read. It only takes three minutes and is easy to understand because very visual. You can find it on our Youtube channel and on our whale shark page.

I am very pleased with the result! It is honest about conditions and physical demands and same as the infographic entails everything you need to know and is easy to share.

The Podcast

Five years ago, we recorded something simple: a guest talking about the experience right after they got back on the boat. Authentic, unscripted, excited. That recording still lives on our site. It is the most honest thing we have ever published about this tour, because it is not us describing the experience, it is one of our guest living it.

How It All Connects: Depending on Where You Book

If you book directly on our website: All four pieces are on the booking page. Video, blog post link, podcast, and now the infographic. You have no excuse to arrive unprepared.

If you reach us through social media or email: We send you the infographic and the explainer video immediately. We link you to the blog post if you want to go deeper.

If you book through an OTA: After your booking confirmation, you will receive a second message from us in the platform chat with the infographic attached and links to the video and blog. We are not going to let the platform communication gap become your gap. I learned this lesson the hard way!

Why This Matters More Than You Might Think

Setting expectations correctly is not about managing complaints. It is about the quality of the day itself.

A guest who knows they are going out on open ocean, who ate a light dinner the night before, took Dramamine, got eight hours of sleep, and understands the boat ride might be long, has a fundamentally different experience than a guest who expected a calm, 20-minute lagoon tour.

Same tour. Same conditions. Different preparation. Different experience.

95% of our guests leave happy and already planning their next trip. That number is not an accident. It is the result of over-communicating before they ever step on the boat.

If you are researching whale shark tours in Cancun, I hope this post is part of what you read before you book, with us or with anyone else. This experience is genuinely extraordinary. It deserves to be experienced by someone who showed up ready for it.

Practical: What to Know Before You Book

Kay Honig is the founder of Kay Tours Mexico, a private tour operator based in Playa del Carmen, Mexico, specializing in whale shark excursions, family tours, and curated experiences along the Riviera Maya, Yucatan and Mexico City.

Reach us at contact@kay.tours or at www.kay.tours.

Frequently Asked Questions

When is the best time to book a whale shark tour?

The whale shark season runs June through mid-September. It is best to book early in your stay to allow for rescheduling if weather conditions change.

What is the difference between early season and mid-season?

In June, sightings are less predictable and conditions can be rougher as the migration begins. By July and August (mid-season), encounters are at their peak and conditions are most consistent.

How should I prepare for motion sickness?

Open ocean conditions often cause motion sickness. We recommend taking Dramamine the night before and again the morning of the tour (not on an empty stomach), regardless of your history with sea sickness.

Is sunscreen allowed on the whale shark tour?

No sunscreen is allowed in the water—even those labeled reef-safe or biodegradable. This is a strictly enforced rule in the federally protected biosphere reserve. Apply it before leaving your hotel and leave it behind.

What are the physical requirements for the excursion?

The tour involves a 5:00 AM pickup, a boat ride ranging from 30 minutes to 3 hours, and physically demanding swimming in open ocean. While a life jacket is mandatory and a guide is present, guests should be prepared for a long and exhausting day.